Michael C. Moynihan, Reason Online, suggests that Kwanzaa is virtually dead:
In the days leading up the Christmas, one couldn’t help but notice that references to Kwanzaa, the decades-old African-American holiday that captured so many dull minds during the Great Culture Wars of the 1990s, were almost nonexistent. Kwanzaa, an Afrocentric celebration of black self-reliance (or something) that so spooked the “war on Christmas” types, has largely disappeared. Back in the day, its champions and critics alike thought it could potentially replace Christmas in the very Christian African-American community.
If Moynihan is correct, will anybody, outside the media, miss it, and will the meiia ever let go of their cherished myth of Kwanzaa? I say no to both.
James Joyner, Outside the Beltway:
Or, perhaps, it was just a fad and, like pet rocks, mood rings, and disco, the novelty wore off.
A fad, or just an artificial holiday without much, if any, reason? Christmas might be diverse in the many different origins of its traditions, but nothing in Christmas excludes black Christians from celebrating. I mean it wasn’t like Baby Jesus was born as the savior for only those of the palor of Caroline Kennedy Schlossberg.
I suggest that the meanings of Christmas are so many and so varied that anybody ought to able to find their own personal meaning in Christmas. This is not to suggest that Linus was somehow wrong, but only that he did not find the one, only and exclusive meaning of the holiday.
In the mean time, you truly put off by the religious aspects of Christmas, there is always Festivus. To one and all a happy Boxing Day Eve.
Tags: african american holiday, baby jesus, boxing day, Caroline Kennedy, christman, culture wars, fad, festivus, James Joyner, kwanzaa, linus, mean time, michael c, mood rings, moynihan, muth, palor, pet rocks, self reliance
December 25th, 2008 at 10:53
We might survive the loss of Kwanzaa, but let us pray that Festivus will still be celebrated. The dance around the Festivus pole and then the traditonal dinner followed by the ritual exchanging of insults is my favorite part.
December 25th, 2008 at 11:16
Isn’t there some rule against Festivus prayers? I migbt try to find some empiral data on the relative popularity of the various holidays.
December 25th, 2008 at 11:57
I, for one find it passing strange that it should be declared dead, the very year that Obama makes it into the White House. I find Ann Coulter made quite a bit of sense eight years back:
So, what is it, then, that President Bush hailed, today, then?
Exactly what Ann says, all those years ago:
by the way, Ann has an updated article posted in Human Events today on this subject.
One can only wonder, if the reported death of the holiday didn’t occur because people have begun to figure out just what it was they were celebrating.
There are certainly, as you suggest, David, a number of meanings that can be easily attached to Christmas. However, I would hasten to point out to you that it to be Christmas, it has to start with Christ, however you perceive him to be. Else, why celebrate such on or near the 25th of December? Why not June 17th? Be a lot warmer.
The thing that sticks in my mind about this more than anything else, is the insistence of breaking away from traditional American culture, while declaring their replacements as equals or superior. It strikes me that so many people are so very desperate to tie themselves onto something that is not additional American culture that they are willing to tie themselves onto anything that passes by… Kwanzaa, Festivus, what-have-you, all because , seemingly, being anti American is “cool”. It means being accepted in certain circles.
Notice the groups that and documents as having started this monstrosity. Now ask yourself; would these groups benefit from the dilution and ultimate destruction of the unique American culture?
December 25th, 2008 at 17:03
“The thing that sticks in my mind about this more than anything else, is the insistence of breaking away from traditional American culture, while declaring their replacements as equals or superior. It strikes me that so many people are so very desperate to tie themselves onto something that is not additional American culture that they are willing to tie themselves onto anything that passes by… Kwanzaa, Festivus, what-have-you, all because , seemingly, being anti American is “coolâ€. It means being accepted in certain circles”
Equal is a mathmatical concept. It is not relevant in the study culture, biology or society. In life, no two groups or ideas are equal.
As to the idea of superior, or inferior, that can not be juded without context. Is a camel superior to a fish? It is in a desert, buyt not in an ocean.
December 26th, 2008 at 0:01
Well, exactly so. Where things start getting tangled is when we start imposing government on culture, biology, and society. The that time alone is that when law gets applied to these, invariably, one group ends up being more equal than the rest to paraphrase Mr. Orwell.
At the risk of getting into a long discussion again about the government’s role vis’a’vie the society, and culture, let me just say that the problems start when government starts trying to make all cultures equal, as opposed to making all people equal before the law.